Submit the question you can't stop arguing about and Sal and Eddie will take sides. You're the jury.
The question people can't agree on. Keep it to one clear question.
✓ Submitted.
Sal and Eddie will take a look. If the guys pick yours, you'll hear it on the show.
Arguments waiting their turn. Upvote the ones you want to hear.
Episode 9
Sal says Connery won every poll ever taken. Eddie says Craig is the only Bond who actually had a story. Who played it best? And who\'s in third? Settle this.
Episode 8
Sal has the odds, the wobble, and Michael Caine. Eddie says the question was never meant to be answered. Inception\'s ending is back on trial.
Episode 7
It\'s one for the ages - is pineapple a valid pizza topping, or do the traditionalists have a point? Sal argues for the Dole lobby, Eddie\'s pleads on behalf of the people of Naples.
Episode 6
Sal has Jordan at 6-for-6 and won\'t budge. Eddie says LeBron\'s still writing the book at 4-10. Who\'s got the stronger case? You tell us!
Episode 5
in answer to a wave of criticism in the YouTube comments, Sal and Eddie debate whether or not they themselves are 100% AI slop. Sal argues yes from inside the blender. Eddie tries to make a musical analogy. Who\'s right? You decide.
Episode 4
We\'ve been arguing about it for nearly 30 years. On Friends, were Ross and Rachel REALLY on a break? Sal and Eddie argue it out and nobody\'s walking away clean.
Episode 3
Sal says the middle seat earns both armrests — Eddie says that\'s just a participation trophy for sitting down. Settle This can\'t land the plane on this one, we need you to help decide
Episode 2
Don the Beachcomber opened first, but Trader Vic\'s Mai Tai conquered the world — Settle This debates who really owns the Tiki throne.
Episode 1
Nick from Washington Heights wants a final answer on the most debated ending in TV history — did Tony Soprano get clipped in that diner booth, or did David Chase do something far stranger? Sal reads the room like a crime scene and puts the odds at 85-15. Eddie says the whole argument is the point, and we\'ve been staring into a black screen for eighteen years like it owes us something. No verdict — just onion rings and existential dread.